National Agricultural Literacy Curriculum Matrix

Search

Inherited Traits in the Living Corn Necklace (Grades 3-5)

Grade Level(s)

3 - 5

Estimated Time

1 hour

Purpose

Students will observe the growth of Indian corn and popcorn seeds, observe similarities and differences between the two varieties, and discuss heredity.

Materials

Activity 1

  • Pictures of crop plants
  • Pictures or ears of dried popcorn and Indian corn

Activity 2

  • Cotton balls, 1 per student*
  • Small plastic jewelry bags, 1 per student*
  • Popcorn seeds, 1 per student*
  • Indian corn seeds, 1 per student*
  • Necklace-length piece of yarn, 1 per student*
  • Water, 1 cup per group 
  • Permanent markers, 1 per group
  • Hand lenses, 1 per student or pair 
  • Metric rulers, 1 per student or pair
  • Pictures of mature popcorn and Indian corn plants 
  • We’re Expecting... activity sheet, 1 per student

*These items are included in the Living Necklace Kit, which is available for purchase.

Essential Files (maps, charts, pictures, or documents)

Vocabulary

cross-pollination: transfer of pollen from one plant to another

ear: female part of a corn plant that contains the cob, the silks, and the eggs that will become kernels

hybrid: produced by cross-pollinating two different inbred parent plants; plants are high-yielding and vigorous but results of saving seed are unreliable

kernel: the seed of a corn plant and the part that we eat

open-pollination: pollination that occurs naturally without human interference; open-pollinated varieties are developed simply by saving seed from the most desirable plants, resulting in high genetic diversity among offspring

self-pollination: transfer of pollen from the male part of a flower to the female part of that same flower or another flower on the same plant; in corn this rarely happens in the field, but it may be done by plant breeders to develop desired traits

tassel: the male part of a corn plant that emerges from the top of the plant and bears many small flowers that release pollen grains

Background Agricultural Connections

Every person (except for an identical twin) has a unique set of inherited traits that makes him or her identifiable as an individual. This is true of all organisms that reproduce sexually. However, have you ever tried to distinguish one bean plant from another bean plant? Or one corn plant from another corn plant? Plants grown as crops have been selected to minimize trait variation because it is easier for farmers to manage a more uniform crop. In this activity, students germinate two types of corn seeds: popcorn and Indian corn. As a result of their observations, students will see that seedlings of the popcorn variety (which have been bred for uniformity) are very similar, while more variation can be observed among the Indian corn seedlings.

Understanding heredity in plants—especially crop plants—can be complicated. Many crop plants are propagated asexually, making it easy to grow a uniform crop. Crops like potatoes, garlic, and raspberries can reproduce simply by being split into pieces from which they will regrow. For example, one garlic plant produces many cloves. If these cloves are separated and replanted, they will grow many, genetically identical garlic plants (like identical twins). Corn does not reproduce in this way.

Every corn plant has both male (tassel) and female (ear) parts. In order for kernels to form on a cob, each one must be fertilized by a grain of pollen. Pollen comes from the tassels at the top of the plant where it is easily picked up by the wind. For fertilization to occur, the pollen must land on a silk strand that sticks out the end of the ear. The pollen is transported down the silk to the egg, which will grow into a kernel after fertilization. As in all organisms that reproduce sexually, the sperm (pollen) and the egg each contribute half of their genes to the offspring (in this case, the corn that will grow from the kernel), creating a genetically unique individual with some traits from each parent.

If farmers select kernels from their best corn plants to save for seed, they know that half of the genes came from the mother plant. However, they do not know anything about the father plants. In the field, most corn silks are pollinated by surrounding plants, a process known as cross-pollination. Because pollen is blown in on the wind (open-pollination), the many kernels on a single ear can be pollinated by many different father plants. Planting the kernels from an open-pollinated ear of corn produces plants as similar as half-brothers or -sisters. In order to select for a more uniform and genetically similar crop, the source of pollen must be controlled—a difficult proposition on a windy day. The ears must be protected from chance pollination and then hand-pollinated with a tassel from the desired father plant. Then, the kernels will produce plants that are as similar as brothers and sisters.

Many farmers and gardeners plant hybrid varieties of corn and other vegetables. It takes years of controlled pollination to develop hybrids. First, a carefully selected plant with desirable characteristics is self-pollinated for seven generations, resulting in an inbred plant. Inbred plants have stunted growth and do not yield well, but when two different inbred plants are cross-pollinated, their progeny grow vigorously, yield well, and reliably express desired traits—these are hybrid varieties. Development of hybrids has greatly increased agricultural productivity, but seed saved from a hybrid is unreliable. For this reason, some gardeners and farmers prefer non-hybrid varieties.

Interest Approach – Engagement

  1. Remind students about the similarities and differences among humans that come from inherited traits. Ask students to list various inherited traits.
  2. Ask students if plants have traits that are inherited through their genetics just like humans. Tell your class that you are going to investigate the genetic variation present in plants.

Procedures

Activity 1: Trait Variation

  1. Remind students about the similarities and differences among humans that come from inherited traits. Tell them that the class is now going to investigate the amount of variation present in crop plants. 
  2. Divide students into groups and provide each group with a picture of a field of crop plants, such as corn, beans, etc. Ask each group to make a chart of the similarities and differences they can see between plants in the pictures. Discuss how the amount of variation they observe compares to the amount of variation that can be observed in humans. As a class, brainstorm reasons why farmers might not want variation among plants they grow to produce crops.
  3. Show each group of students an ear of dried popcorn and an ear of Indian corn. If you do not have ears of corn available, you can use pictures or have students compare all of the popcorn seeds and all of the Indian corn seeds that will be used in Activity 2. 
  4. Ask each group to make a chart of similarities and differences between the kernels on an ear (each kernel is an individual offspring of the plant that produced the ear). As a class, discuss their observations. Discuss the possible sources of variation (sexual reproduction, open pollination). Also compare the traits of the two corn varieties. 
  5. Explain to the students that in general, it is easier for farmers to manage uniform crops. For example, most corn is harvested using a machine called a combine. All of the corn is harvested at the same time, so it is best if it all matures at the same time. However, sometimes variation is desirable. Indian corn is used mostly for ornamental purposes, so variation in the color of the kernels is desirable. 

Activity 2: Living Corn Necklace

  1. Tell the students that they will continue their investigation of corn by observing how corn seeds germinate and begin to grow. They will observe two varieties, Indian corn and popcorn, that have been selected over time for different traits. 
  2. Provide each student with one popcorn seed and one Indian corn seed. Ask each student to begin his or her corn journal by drawing a picture of each seed and writing several sentences to describe it. 
  3. Provide groups with the materials needed for each student to make a “Living Necklace” (plastic jewelry bag, cotton balls, and yarn), permanent marker(s) and a cup of water. Use the Living Necklace Tutorial, or simply direct students to make their necklaces as follows:
    • Use the permanent marker to label one side of the bag P and the other side I.
    • Dip a cotton ball in water so that it is thoroughly wet but not dripping. Excess water will cause the seeds not to sprout.
    • Place the cotton ball in the small plastic bag.
    • Put one popcorn seed on the side of the cotton ball facing the label P.
    • Put one Indian corn seed on the other side of the cotton ball, facing the label I. The labels will help students remember which seed is which.
    • Seal the bag. String the yarn through the hole in the jewelry bag. Tie a knot in the end of the string to form a necklace. 
    • Bags can be hung from tacks on a bulletin board and taken down for student observations. 
    • Teaching Tip: The corn seeds will sprout in three to six days. Starting on a Friday and making the first observations on Monday will speed up this activity. 
  4. For one week have students record in their journals the changes they observe in their seeds, including information about observable traits such as: number of days from “planting” until the root and the shoot can be seen; root and shoot lengths and color; and number of leaves and roots. 
    • Use hand lenses to observe the roots and shoots as they emerge and grow.
    • Use rulers to measure the length of roots and leaves as they grow.
    • Teaching Tip: It is difficult to take the seedlings out of the bags and get them back in without breaking the roots. Ask students to measure through the bag instead. The roots will curl, so you may want to suggest measuring them in sections and estimating as necessary.
  5. In small groups, have students make charts or graphs of the data they collected for measurable traits (leaf and root length). Ask them to look for differences between the popcorn and Indian corn.
  6. As a class, discuss how each group compared their data for popcorn and Indian corn. Which kinds of charts or graphs worked the best? Were there noticeable differences between the popcorn and Indian corn seedlings?
  7. Discuss how plant breeders control inheritance and work to develop seeds that will reliably express desired traits. Popcorn has been selected for different traits than Indian corn.
  8. Compare the traits of the corn seedlings to those of mature corn plants (using photographs). 
  9. Use the We’re Expecting... activity sheet to review the difference between cross-pollination and self-pollination and to introduce the concept of dominant and recessive traits. 

Concept Elaboration and Evaluation

After conducting these activities, review and summarize the following key concepts:

  • Plants inherit specific traits from the parent plant just like humans or animals inherit traits from their parents.
  • Farmers use science and genetics to improve their crops.

Essential Links

Enriching Activities

  • Assign students to compare similarities and differences in traits among plants of a species growing in the wild and among plants of another cultivated species. 

  • Use In the Three Sisters Garden: Native American Stories and Seasonal Activities for the Curious Child by JoAnne Dennee, et al. to incorporate stories from Native American history and integrate fifth grade social studies curriculum. 

  • If you'd like to teach your students the difference between a monocot and dicot, use a corn seed and a bean seed in their living necklace.  You can also find more resources and information in the Seeds, Miraculous Seeds lesson.

  • Use the lesson plan Peas in a Pod to further explore heredity by modeling the probability of dominant and recessive trait inheritance with the Punnett square.

  • Grow Fast Plants®, and use the activities in Spiraling Through Life with Fast Plants: An Inquiry-Rich Manual by Robin Greenler to follow germination, growth and development, flowering, and pollination. 

  • Grow the Brassica butterfly, which lives on Fast Plants®, enabling students to observe the life cycle stages of an insect undergoing metamorphosis from egg to adult butterfly in just 26 days. Brassica butterfly eggs are available from Carolina Science and Math (Item #144100).

Suggested Companion Resources

Agricultural Literacy Outcomes

Science, Technology, Engineering & Math

  • Identify examples of how the knowledge of inherited traits is applied to farmed plants and animals in order to meet specific objectives (i.e., increased yields, better nutrition, etc.) (T4.3-5.c)
  • Provide examples of science being applied in farming for food, clothing, and shelter products (T4.3-5.d)

Education Content Standards

Within SCIENCE

3-LS3: Heredity: Inheritance and Variation of Traits

  • 3-LS3-1
    3-LS3-1
    Analyze the interpret data to provide evidence that plants and animals have traits inherited from parents and that variation of these traits exists in a group of similar organisms.

State specific Standards and Objectives

State Standards for MN

State Standards for UT

Common Core Connections

Reading: Anchor Standards

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.R.1
    CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.R.1
    Read closely to determine what the text says explicitly and to make logical inferences from it; cite specific textual evidence when writing or speaking to support conclusions drawn from the text.

Speaking and Listening: Anchor Standards

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.SL.1
    CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.SL.1
    Prepare for and participate effectively in a range of conversations and collaborations with diverse partners, building on others’ ideas and expressing their own clearly and persuasively.

Language: Anchor Standards

  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.L.1
    CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.L.1
    Demonstrate command of the conventions of standard English grammar and usage when writing or speaking.
  • CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.L.4
    CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.CCRA.L.4
    Determine or clarify the meaning of unknown and multiple-meaning words and phrases by using context clues, analyzing meaningful word parts, and consulting general and specialized reference materials, as appropriate.

 

Creative Commons License